Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Caprese Salad
Garlic Bread with Melted Mozzarella Cheese
12" Hot Italian Sub
12" Double Meat Hot Italian Sub
About
Pizza Chef
Welcome to Pizza Chef, a delightful pizzeria nestled at 5501 Fruitville Rd, Sarasota, FL. This family-owned gem has captured the hearts (and appetites) of locals for over 23 years. Managed by the warm and welcoming duo, Karen and Frank, Pizza Chef is not just about pizza—it's about passion, quality, and community.
Step inside, and you’ll immediately notice the cozy atmosphere that invites you to sit back and relax. The air is filled with enticing aromas, hinting at the carefully crafted menu that awaits you. Pizza Chef specializes in hand-tossed pizzas that boast a perfect balance of crispy and thin crust—a detail that customers like Hasan Ucar have raved about, describing the pizza as “incredible” and “unforgettable.” With sauces made from scratch and toppings that are fresh and generously applied, each slice is a celebration of flavor.
But the culinary magic doesn’t stop at pizza. Reviewers highlight the Hot Italian sub as a must-try, packed with high-quality meats and cheeses, all on a homemade roll that is baked to perfection. Gayle calls it a “hidden gem” and expresses excitement to return, while Gina Shank reminds us that the menu includes mouthwatering options like lasagna, Strombolis, and a richly packed antipasto salad, perfect for those seeking variety.
Pizza Chef is more than just its delicious offerings; it’s about the friendly faces that greet you. Regulars appreciate the personal touch, with a friendly head nod from Frank or a smile from Marcy enhancing the dining experience. This welcoming environment makes it a great spot for takeout, especially convenient for busy days. The essence of family runs deep, not just in ownership but in the strong ties within the community.
For those in Sarasota looking for outstanding pizza and more, Pizza Chef is ready to impress with its dedication to quality, flavor-fueled dishes, and a genuinely welcoming vibe. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just seeking comfort food, your taste buds are in for a treat. Call them at +1 941-378-1126 and prepare for a delightful experience that is sure to become a favorite.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Pizza in Sarasota doesn't cut it compared to your typical northern pizza but this is pretty darn good. Great sauce, they don't skimp on cheese, and the crust is soft but crunchy. Yum. ”
“ Hidden gem!! Hot Italian sub is amazing. Fresh high quality meats and cheese on homemade roll baked to perfection. I did takeout, and look forward to returning soon! ”
“ Incredible Pizza! It was unforgettable! The dough was perfectly hand-tossed, with just the right balance of crispy and thin. The sauces were rich and flavorful, clearly made from scratch, and the toppings were fresh, vibrant, and generously applied. ”
“ Always our go-to pizza place. Their lasagna & Strombolis are amazing too. Antipasto salad: full of goodies! Usually no crowd, big take out biz & always a head nod from Frank, a smile from Karen & Marcy. Family run, small business. ”
“ Family owned ,been there for the past 23 years ,run by Karen and Frank, who are very friendly, the place is so nice and calm, and the food, one of the best meat lasagne and the Italian onion soup we had,waiting to try their pizza too soon, highly recommended. ”
“ Best big slice NY style pizza in Sarasota! Had a slice of cheese with sausage and pepperoni and a Sicilian slice. The Sicilian crust just crumbles in your mouth, very awesome! The NY slice is thin with no flop and the cheese doesn't slide off on a vertical. 5 and a half a slice for a 2 topper! Come get some. Dave would give this cheese slice an 8.1 easy. I give it an 8.6! ;) ”
“ We order here weekly and it’s truly the most consistently delicious pie around. We are from NJ so we initially found it very difficult to find edible pizza around here but Pizza Chef is one of the only places that really feels like we ordered from up north. Karen is also a sweetheart. Five stars. ”
“ KAREN is always friendly makes me feel at home being from New York it's one of my favorite pizza spots that reminds of home. ”